CITYSAFE PODCAST
The CitySafe Podcast explores how retailers, loss prevention teams, and the people responsible for safety navigate theft, incidents, and risk in environments where what you know, and what you do about it, can carry real legal weight.
Co-hosted by Jim Cords, retired from the federal side, whose career spanned the FBI, DHS, and OIG, and Don Carr, who has owned and operated private security guard companies and architected security systems, the CitySafe Podcast focuses on the space between detection and response, where so much of retail security actually plays out.
The CitySafe Podcast reflects the personal views and opinions of its hosts and is a conversation, not professional advice. Rather than offering tactics or prescriptions, it examines how knowledge, duty, documentation, and the choice to act are understood differently across retail environments, and why the same approach does not protect every operator the same way. Listeners should consult their own qualified professionals on questions of legal liability, operational risk, security, and compliance specific to their circumstances and jurisdictions.
Available on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, and YouTube Music.
CITYSAFE PODCAST
Ep. 42: Hands Off · Use of Force in Retail Loss Prevention
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Use of force in retail loss prevention: the physical moment takes four seconds and the litigation takes four years. Don Carr argues the sales floor's frustration — "so my job is to just watch?" — and Jim Cords answers with the arithmetic behind hands-off policies: force protecting property is judged far more harshly than force protecting people, and shopkeeper's privilege is three jury questions wearing one sentence. The escalation trap that starts with a grabbed sleeve, the contractor gap between guard post orders and store policy, and disengagement trained as a skill. The merchandise is never worth the injury. Loss. Liability. Law.
This is the City Safe Podcast, a conversation at the intersection of community safety, technology, and leadership, co-hosted by Don Carr and Jim Kortz. Together, we examine the critical issues facing cities today and the smarter tools that can help reduce crime and protect our communities. From instant communication systems to emerging technology, we break down what works, what doesn't, and what's next for urban safety. Because in today's world, keeping people safe requires more than good intentions. It requires innovation, data, and decisive action. Listen to the City Safe Podcast, available now on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, and YouTube Music. Subscribe today and join the mission to make cities safer for everyone.
SPEAKER_00So every policy manual in retail has the same sentence. Use only reasonable force. And every jury that's ever heard one of these cases has asked the same question. Reasonable to whom?
SPEAKER_01Decided later by 12 people who weren't there watching your worst four seconds on a loop. That's the episode today, really. The physical moment takes four seconds. The litigation takes four years. The ratio between those numbers should govern everything a store trains. I'm Don Carr. I'm Jim Cords. Welcome to the City Safe Podcast. Use of force is the topic. The one everything else on the show has been circling around.
SPEAKER_00And I'm going to make an argument here, Jim, from the floor side, because there's real frustration that lives under this. Teams watch merchandise walk out every day. Corporate says hands off. And the associate thinks, what? So my job is just to watch?
SPEAKER_01Right. So let me answer that. Well, hands off isn't being timid, and it's not a it's not a surrender. It's arithmetic. The major retailers I've already run. Force protecting people gets judged one way. Force protecting property gets judged much, much more harshly. A takedown over a $60 backpack and the same takedown after somebody swung first, they're the same physical act, but completely different lawsuits, which produces the rule that offends every instinct in the building.
SPEAKER_00Right. So the bottom line is the merchandise is never worth the injury. Never. Not theirs, not the suit, not the associates. And that's the duty you owe your people, right? And workers comp is the good outcome in that scenario. And the answer to, so I just watch is no. You observe, you be a good witness, you document, you become the reason the case holds. The camera detects, but the human records. That's not passivity. That's the job the courtroom actually rewards. Now, Jim, let's get into the shopkeeper's privilege because a lot of times that can be misconstrued as a shield.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, and Don, I think it's a narrower than a lot of people think. So broadly, and of course this varies, a merging can detain a suspected thief using reasonable force for a reasonable time in a reasonable manner. There's that's three reasonables, and every one is a jury decision. That's not a shield, that's three separate opportunities to be second guessed.
SPEAKER_00Absolutely. And we're gonna walk those failure modes because you know this is really an extension of that episode we did several weeks ago, Jim, of this shopkeeper's privilege. It's a big deal. So let's jump into the escalation trap first, because it's the more common one. Stop starts verbal, suspect pushes past, an associate grabs a sleeve. That grab converts everything. Contact, resistance, force, it all ratchets up, right? And in the deposition, the whole event gets read backward from the injury. The question won't be, did he steal? It'll be who touched whom first and why. So let's get into the contractor gap, Jim. Okay.
SPEAKER_01So if you've ever hired security guards, their post orders and your policy need to be functionally one document. They need to be the same. If the guard company authorizes force, your policy prohibits, or nobody ever checked on that, that's two standards, and opposing counsel will find that seam. The indemnification clause moves money, it doesn't make video disappear.
SPEAKER_00That's right. And somebody from receiving sprints past the registers to help, right? No training, no role, maximum exposure. And a jury won't distinguish between your LP team and your stock room. So your policy can't either. It has to govern everyone in uniform.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, correct. Very well said. So let's talk about the doctrine, writing it down. And when you write, when you document, do it for the worst reader on the worst day. So reasonable force is a conclusion, not an instruction. So say what's authorized, blocking a path, escorting, breaking away from a grab, and also say what's not authorized. I think very important. Strikes, anything near the neck, prone restraint or weapons, sentences with adjectives get litigated, but sentences with nouns get followed.
SPEAKER_00Absolutely. So the the training gap that really nobody fills is the disengagement as a skill set, right? Teams drill the takedown they'll never legally use and never practice the walk away they'll need weekly. Right? Letting go, creating distance, narrating to the camera, and after any contact, any contact, the full package in the first hour. Report, footage before it cycles, documented injuries, offer of medical, and really make sure that everything is recorded. So let's run the frame, Jim. What's the loss?
SPEAKER_01Well, the lost on is whatever walk out the door, which is replaceable, insured or not, and priced in ahead of time.
SPEAKER_00And the liability? Well, the four seconds, right? The only tool on this show that gets more expensive, the better it works. And what's the law?
SPEAKER_01The law is those three reasonables, judged in hindsight. Protect people with everything you've got. Protect property with a camera and a phone call.
SPEAKER_00Next week, ten feet that change everything. The suspects out the door, your associates three steps behind, and the sidewalk becomes the courtroom. I'm Don Carr. I'm Jim Cords. Stay well, stay aware, and stay city safe.
SPEAKER_02That wraps up this episode of the City Safe Podcast. Thanks for joining us in the conversation about smarter strategies for safer cities. If you found today's discussion valuable, share it with your network and help us spread awareness about the tools and technology making a real impact. Be sure to subscribe on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, and YouTube Music so you never miss an episode. Until next time, stay informed, stay connected, and stay city safe.